education ruined me
Thursday, August 25th, 2005This article is about “how availability of information affects ones thinking”, and argue why “I didnot discover the laws of gravity, though my home is in an apple orchid.”
I will begin with my childhood, when they first told me that “the world is not flat, and its gol[1]. And thats why we won’t fall if we go on travelling.” It didnt made sense to me at all. How does earth’s being gol help me not to fall? What difference does it bring to me by making it gol than flat. And my gol was gol as in disc.[2] And this was a mystery for me to know, why the hell we won’t fall. I tried to ask this doubt couple of times from my teacher, but did not get satisfactory answer. Probably he didnt know how to answer this stupid question. coz i didnt mention that by gol i meant a disc.[3] And one fine day, when i myself discovered that by gol they meant gol as in a ball, and not as in a disc… i made the biggest discovery of all time. And I was feeling greater than any Galelio.[4]
And about the Apple thing… it was made too obvious to me that the earth sucks and i didnt get the oppertunity to ask why does the apple fall. I remember to have simpler questions like why does then “flame goes upward”, but i never again got the same feeling that i had after discovering that earth is gol, and thats why we don’t fall, and yeah.. gol as in a ball. Yeah… there are many things left to be discovered, but my point is that our approach is entirely different. We are not training ourselves towards discoveries.[7]
People always told me that you should try to ask your doubts from your teachers and get them solved. They never told me that keep your doubts with yourself and go on thinking about them. Keep several background processes. I have not met a single person, who said that keep your doubts and think about them. They always guided me toward the easiest source of answeres. And once you get the answer, thinking stops. There is no mystery left to be solved.[5] And thinking is the mental exercise. Remembering is no way a mental exercise. And thats what we have done all our educational life. Remembering all that they teach.
I don’t mean to rediscover all laws, and start science from scratch everytime. But before you look for the answer, make sure that you have given it a try, exercised your brain on that problem. And the educational system is exactly opposite. My science class was no different than my history class. “He discovered that and he did that experiment and bla bla….”. My science class was the class of ‘History of Science’.
I really feel fortunate that, i didnt get good teachers, who were able to solve all my doubts. They even didnt make the things clear to me. And I was left with lots of doubts, to think about. And best example of that is my intermediate physics. And at the end of the course my knowledge of physics was much more strong and clear than my teacher. I also had the tendency of not asking doubts. Probably I was shy or it was part of attitude. I will call it attitude, but people mostly call it shyness.[6] This attitude helped me to keep my doubts with myself and do more parallel processing. I tried to save myself as much as possible from the educational system from spoiling me, and stayed out of it as much as possible. But i know lots of friends who never came out of it.
Is it that the system is wrong ? or i am wrong ? or the system is designed for some other kind of people and i was an exception to it ?
I am not a great scientist, and if the same article was written by some very great scientist, it would had carried much significance, and made intellectual people think about it.
- smr
“I was born intelligent, but education ruined me”.
[1] i’m intentionally not using english here. coz thats what they told me.
[2] ambiguity of the language.
[3] coz i was not thinking in that direction.
[4] not having a globe in the village school help me here.
[5] i’m getting a feeling that my writing is getting inspired by Osho.
[6] Yeah.. shyness is also an attitude. But the difference is one is “by choice”.
[7] No one trained great scientists, but can’t we make an Einstein out of a common man ?






